Delaware Concealed Carry Forum
General Gun Discussion => Ammunition and Re-Loading => Topic started by: Condition 1 on May 13, 2013, 02:29:44 AM
-
Funny
http://www.youtube.com/watch?annotation_id=annotation_730404&feature=iv&src_vid=sf60pYjH9-g&v=zHkqOWzDAZI
-
hehe, nice !
-
That was great! His .45 video almost made me cry
-
According to an article written by an LA detective, who compiled LA police shooting stastics, it takes (on average) 4-5 shots from a .45 to stop an attacker, and 5-6 shots from a 9mm.
-
Wouldn't that depend on where you hit your attacker? People have been killed with one shot from a small caliber pistol if it is a brain or heart shot.
I carry a 9mm myself with hollow points.
-
According to an article written by an LA detective, who compiled LA police shooting stastics, it takes (on average) 4-5 shots from a .45 to stop an attacker, and 5-6 shots from a 9mm.
Those numbers seem so high for both calibers. I'm in my early 20's, 6'2" and about 230lbs and I feel like getting shot once with either would be a come to Jesus moment. I wonder if they are talking about 5-6 shots fired and 1-2 hit, or maybe every criminal in LA is Wolverine.
-
There are many variables to consider; range, type of bullet, amount of clothing, bullet entry location, etc.
So you would have to see all the statistics to make an accurate statement.
-
I'm sure a few well-placed 9mm hollow-point rounds would prove effective...
but I carry twenty-one rounds of full power DoubleTap 10mm. I'm a pessimist, or an a$$h0le, depending on who you ask. ;D
-
OR....Maybe the LAPD are just poor shots?
-
I'm sure a few well-placed 9mm hollow-point rounds would prove effective...
but I carry twenty-one rounds of full power DoubleTap 10mm. I'm a pessimist, or an a$$h0le, depending on who you ask. ;D
No sir, not a pessimist. Just an extremely well prepared realist. ;D
-
I posted this on a different forum, and thought it might be helpful here too...
Check out this article:
http://www.americanrifleman.org/articles/handgun-stopping-power/ (http://www.americanrifleman.org/articles/handgun-stopping-power/)
Page 2 shows a chart of common handgun calibers and their statistics...velocity - penetration - expansion.
There are a few 9mm rounds that exceed the penetration and overall expansion size of most .40 and .45 calibers. For example...the DoubleTap 124 Gr. Bonded JHP 9mm penetrated 15.0" and expanded by a factor of 1.97. This results in an expansion size of 0.697". For the .45 to equal that final expanded size, it would have to expand by a factor of 1.55...some did, but most did not. Same for the .40 - it would have to expand by a factor of 1.74 to equal that of this particular 9mm round...some did, but most did not. The .40's and .45's that did exceed the expansion of this 9mm, most did not have the same penetration.
DISCLAIMER -- I'm not a math wiz, so there may be some mistakes in my calculations
So, it would appear the average performance of the .40's and .45's does exceed that of the average 9mm, but there are a few 9mm rounds that outperform most .40's and .45's.
-
Remember, the report I cited said "on average", meaning all things considered, clothing, misses, etc. I read a story about a police officer and a large criminal, who both emptied .45 auto's into each other without misses, and both got away and survived.
-
Shoot the gun that you can shoot well. It'll do the job.
-
Remember, the report I cited said "on average", meaning all things considered, clothing, misses, etc. I read a story about a police officer and a large criminal, who both emptied .45 auto's into each other without misses, and both got away and survived.
Frank, just poking fun at you. :)
-
I'm sure a few well-placed 9mm hollow-point rounds would prove effective...
but I carry twenty-one rounds of full power DoubleTap 10mm. I'm a pessimist, or an a$$h0le, depending on who you ask. ;D
You never fail to amaze me.
-
According to an article written by an LA detective, who compiled LA police shooting stastics, it takes (on average) 4-5 shots from a .45 to stop an attacker, and 5-6 shots from a 9mm.
We have been discussing an example on this site of a dead thug who got hit by one 9mm round
-
According to an article written by an LA detective, who compiled LA police shooting stastics, it takes (on average) 4-5 shots from a .45 to stop an attacker, and 5-6 shots from a 9mm.
We have been discussing an example on this site of a dead thug who got hit by one 9mm round
Maybe we can add the importance of having one in the pipe.
-
According to an article written by an LA detective, who compiled LA police shooting stastics, it takes (on average) 4-5 shots from a .45 to stop an attacker, and 5-6 shots from a 9mm.
We have been discussing an example on this site of a dead thug who got hit by one 9mm round
Maybe we can add the importance of having one in the pipe.
I wondered every time I heard "A bullet in the chamber" from the prosecution or media I had to think what dang good is a gun without a round chambered.
-
I cannot vouch for the accuracy of this information as it was quoted on a defensive handgun training video. However, in the the video, it was referenced that a study was conducted of the trauma results of handgun shooting incidents. The results were simply tabulated based upon the outcome (live or die). It was found that 97% of individuals hit only once by a handgun round survived the ordeal. And, 80% survival rate for 2 or more hits. I think that this speaks as much to superb trauma care after a shooting, than probably any thing else. There is much to consider in these numbers. Survival could mean many things, such as permanently disabled or alive but in a coma.
The point of the instructor in the video was that if you get hit during a defensive action, keep fighting as you have a very good chance of survival even if you are hit twice. Obviously, I would not recommend testing the results of the study.